BDGL / Insights / Pricing

Tiered pricing for B2B services, and the decoy tier problem

Tiered pricing for B2B services, and the decoy tier problem

The advice is always the same: add a third package nobody is meant to buy, so the middle one looks sensible. The research behind that trick stopped holding up in 2014, and a B2B service is close to the worst case for it. Tiers still earn their place, for a different reason.

A services firm with one price eventually gets asked for options. Not because the price was wrong, but because the buyer needs something to compare it against, and if you hand them nothing they will find a competitor to play that role.

So you build three packages. The real question is what the three are allowed to differ on, and the standard advice, which is to add a deliberately overpriced top tier so the middle one looks reasonable, rests on research that has been in trouble for more than a decade.

Tiers are a scope decision wearing a pricing costume

Most tiered pricing for B2B services fails for one reason: the three packages differ only in quantity. Four reports, eight reports, twelve reports, at 1x, 1.8x and 2.4x. It looks like a pricing structure and it is really a volume discount with extra steps.

That shape teaches the buyer that your work is a commodity sold by the unit, which is the single thing a services firm cannot afford to teach. It also makes the top tier impossible to justify, because nobody needs twelve of something they are not yet sure they need four of.

Tiers earn their place when each one answers a different question about risk and involvement rather than a different number. Who does the work. How fast you answer. How much of the problem you own. What happens when it goes wrong.

What this covers
What this covers

Where the good-better-best advice actually comes from

The decoy tier has an academic pedigree, and it is worth knowing how thin it has become. The underlying finding is the attraction effect, also called the asymmetric dominance effect, first reported by Huber, Payne and Puto in 1982: adding an inferior third option to a choice set raises the share of the option it most resembles.

In 2014 the Journal of Marketing Research published The Limits of Attraction by Shane Frederick, Leonard Lee and Ernest Baskin, volume LI, pages 487 to 507. Their argument is that the effect "may be restricted to stylized product representations in which every product dimension is represented by a number", and that such effects "do not typically occur when consumers experience the product" or "when even one of the product attributes is represented perceptually". They identified only five published studies that had found the effect using stimuli that were not highly stylized, and wrote: "we could not replicate the results of any of these studies". They end by questioning the practical significance of the effect.

Read that against what you are actually selling. A B2B service is close to the worst case for the decoy effect: the attributes are not numbers, the buyer cannot score seniority or responsiveness on a scale, and much of the judgement is perceptual, formed from how you ran the call and what the proposal looked like. The conditions under which the effect reliably appears are close to the opposite of a services pitch.

This does not mean three tiers are a bad idea. It means the reason to have three tiers is not that the third one manipulates the choice. It is that three genuinely different scopes let a buyer locate themselves.

How many tiers, and the evidence on that too

The other half of the folklore is that more options paralyse the buyer. That claim has had a similar run. Scheibehenne, Greifeneder and Todd published a meta-analytic review of choice overload in the Journal of Consumer Research, volume 37 number 3, pages 409 to 425, covering 63 conditions from 50 published and unpublished experiments with 5,036 participants. They found a mean effect size of virtually zero, with considerable variance between studies.

So neither the decoy argument for a third tier nor the overload argument against a fourth has strong evidence behind it. Three is a reasonable default for a practical reason instead: it is the largest number of scopes most service firms can actually staff and deliver differently.

At a glance
At a glance

What the tiers should differ on

Four dimensions carry real weight in services, and they are the ones a buyer is already worried about.

  • Who does the work. A named senior person on the account, versus a team with senior review, versus a team with scheduled review. This is the difference buyers pay most for and the one proposals describe least.
  • Response time. Same working day, two working days, weekly cycle. Write the number down. An unstated response time defaults in the buyer's head to immediate and in yours to when convenient.
  • Scope of ownership. You advise, you execute, or you own the outcome including the parts that need chasing other people. The third is dramatically more expensive and almost nobody prices it that way.
  • Reporting and access. A monthly summary, a monthly working session, or a standing seat in their planning. Access is a real cost and it is the easiest thing to give away for free.

Build the floor for each tier from capacity before you look at the price, because a tier you cannot deliver at the promised response time is a liability rather than a product. The three bases for setting the number, and which one survives a negotiation, are in how to price a B2B service you can defend.

The middle tier is the product, so design it first

Work the middle tier out before the other two. It should be the scope you want most clients on: the one you can staff repeatedly, at a margin you would accept for two years, for the buyer you most want more of.

Then the bottom tier is that scope with the expensive parts removed, honestly labelled, priced so it is not a bargain. And the top tier is the one you would genuinely rather sell, priced as if you mean it, because sometimes a buyer picks it and you have to be able to deliver.

The test for the top tier is simple and it is where the decoy logic breaks: if you would be embarrassed to deliver it, do not list it. A tier you are not prepared to fulfil is a bluff, and the buyers most likely to call it are the large ones.

Write them so procurement can compare them

Three tiers in prose get compared on price, because price is the only row that lines up. Put them in a table with one row per dimension and a filled cell in every tier, including the cells where the answer is no.

DimensionEssentialCoreEmbedded
Who works on itTeam, scheduled reviewTeam, named senior leadNamed senior lead, hands on
Response timeWeekly cycleTwo working daysSame working day
OwnershipWe advise, you executeWe execute in our laneWe own the result end to end
AccessMonthly reportMonthly working sessionIn your planning meetings

An empty cell reads as an oversight and invites a question you will answer badly on the call. A cell that says "not included at this tier" reads as a decision. That difference also shapes how the conversation goes once the deal reaches the people whose job is to compress it, which is covered in negotiating with procurement.

Tiers change the shape of the price objection too. Instead of defending one number, you are asking which scope they want, and that is a better conversation to be in. The sequence for it is in handling price objections without discounting.

When tiers are the wrong structure

Tiers assume the work repeats. Where it does not, they misfire in predictable ways.

If every engagement is genuinely bespoke, three packages are a fiction you will spend every call apologising for. If one client is most of your revenue, tiers tell that client they are on a menu. And if the decision is really between a standing commitment and a one-off piece of work, the cash flow and incentive effects run in opposite directions and that choice comes first. Software firms hit the same fork, and the question of who carries the overrun is the same question: fixed price or hourly, and who is carrying the fat tail is a useful read across, and the services version is in retainer versus project pricing.

Honest limits

We have no evidence that three tiers sell more than one price. The research above is evidence against the standard justification, not evidence for an alternative. What we can defend is that tiers built from scope are easier to deliver and easier to raise later than tiers built from volume.

The replication debate is not settled. Simonson and others have contested the 2014 replication failures, largely on how the stimuli were constructed. The honest summary is that the effect is fragile and context dependent, not that it has been disproved. Either way it is a thin foundation for a pricing page.

Both studies are Western and mostly consumer. We used them because they are published and open, and we have found no equivalent for B2B services buyers in Egypt or the Gulf. We are not going to extrapolate one.

Tiers make raising prices harder, not easier. A named tier becomes a reference point the client expects to persist, and moving it later is a visible change rather than a quiet one. That is a real cost of the structure and the sequence for paying it is in raising prices with existing clients.

Trying to turn one price into three packages without inventing the difference?

Send us your current scope and price, the two client types you see most, and what you refuse to do at any price. We will come back with three tiers built from capacity, the rows to put in the comparison table, and the one you should expect most buyers to pick.

Book a Free Consultation

Read next