How to tell a champion from a friendly contact
How to identify a champion in B2B sales: the access, influence and personal stake tests, the four contacts you actually meet, and what the research omits.
ReadBDGL / Insights / Partnerships
Most partnership openers describe the sender. The research on who to approach is more interesting than the research on what to say, and it rules out the place almost everybody looks first.
The first message to a potential business partner is almost always written from the wrong side of the desk. It opens with who you are, what you have built, and what you are looking for. All three are about you, and none of them is the reason anyone replies.
A partnership approach is not a sales approach with the price removed. In a sale you are offering something the buyer may want. In a partnership you are asking somebody to spend their own credibility and their own pipeline on you, which is a larger ask than a purchase order, and the opener has to earn it.
Before the wording, the choice of target. Two INSEAD strategy professors, Andrew Shipilov and Ithai Stern, summarised four studies from a Strategic Management Journal special issue on alliances, and two of their findings change who should be on your list at all (INSEAD Knowledge, forming corporate alliances that get results).
The first comes from a study of 142 Canadian biotechnology start-ups. Firms with more upstream and downstream partnerships generally performed better, but industry association ties were, in the authors’ words, "a significant drag on performance", and start-ups that partnered with potential rivals at launch "were on thin ice". The association point is worth sitting with, because association membership is exactly where most people go looking for partners.
The second comes from a study of 367 United States software companies tracked from 1990 to 2001, and it is about power. A more powerful partner may take most of the benefits of the alliance. The suggested counter is uncomfortable and correct: reduce dependence by also allying with that partner’s competitors.
Read together, those two findings produce a target list that looks nothing like the usual one. Not the biggest name who might say yes, and not the people in the same association as you. Someone adjacent, with their own customers, who is not large enough to absorb all the value and not close enough to be a competitor.
The practical rule is one sentence long. The first message should describe a revenue event in the partner’s business that happens more often if they work with you, and nothing else.
That rules out most openers people send. It rules out the capability paragraph, because a list of what you can do is a description of your business. It rules out the mutual benefit sentence, because mutual is an assertion and the partner has no reason to accept it from a stranger. And it rules out the vision paragraph entirely.
| Common opener | What the partner hears | What to send instead |
|---|---|---|
| "We are a leading provider of..." | A supplier is pitching me | The deal of theirs you think stalls, and why |
| "I think there is mutual benefit here" | You want access to my clients | One named situation where you would be useful to them |
| "Could we set up a call to explore synergies?" | An hour I will not get back | A specific question they can answer in two lines |
| "We work with companies like yours" | Nothing. This is true of everyone | What you noticed about their business specifically |
The test for the draft is mechanical. Delete every sentence whose subject is your company. If what remains does not contain a reason for them to reply, the message was never about them.
Partnership conversations rarely die at the opener. They die three weeks later, in the gap where both sides are being polite and neither is committing anything, and the research is unusually direct about why.
Ranjay Gulati, Tarun Khanna and Nitin Nohria interviewed 143 managers across seventeen organisations engaged in alliances and published the result in MIT Sloan Management Review in Spring 1994 (Unilateral Commitments and the Importance of Process in Alliances). Their argument is that waiting for the other side to move first is the wrong model. Where each partner is crucial to the outcome, they write, "it is advisable for each to make unilateral commitments to ensure the venture’s success".
A unilateral commitment in the second message is small and real. Making an introduction they did not ask for. Sending the list of accounts you will not approach. Doing one piece of the work before anything is signed. It costs you something whether or not the partnership happens, which is precisely what makes it a signal rather than a sentence.
The same paper carries the figure that explains most dead partnerships. It cites a Coopers and Lybrand study in which executives spent 8 percent of their time actually managing the alliance, against 23 percent on developing plans and 19 percent on legal documents. Three times as much effort on the paperwork as on the relationship the paperwork describes.
Four things, and they fit on one page. Who owns the customer relationship. What each side does and by when. How revenue is attributed when both sides touched a deal. And how either party exits without a dispute.
Attribution is the one that causes the arguments, because it is the one everyone assumes is obvious. It is not, and the shape of the answer depends on the model you have chosen rather than on goodwill: the three models and what each actually costs to run are set out in B2B partnerships strategy, ranked by effort, and the ownership question specifically, of whether you or the partner holds the end customer, is decided by that same choice.
The clause-level detail belongs after that conversation, not before it. When you get there, the clauses that matter in a channel partner agreement is the checklist, and the part everybody skips is what happens next: signing changes nothing is the honest account of the month after the handshake.
Given the finding about association ties, the sourcing question is not rhetorical. The routes that produce partners with their own customers rather than their own membership badge are set out in six real routes to channel partners in the Gulf, and the one that works most often is unglamorous: ask your existing customers who else they already pay.
That question has a property nothing else on the list has. It returns companies that have already been chosen by the exact buyer you want, which is a stronger qualification than anything you could assess from outside.
The failure-rate numbers in this field are not usable and we are not going to quote one as fact. The INSEAD piece opens by citing a study in which "around 80 percent of companies reported that the vast majority of strategic partnerships fail", and does not describe that study’s sample or method. The MIT Sloan paper notes separately that "several studies have reported failure rates as high as 80 percent". Other published estimates sit near 50 percent. They disagree because they define failure differently, some as dissolution and some as not meeting objectives, and because the samples are not comparable. Plan against the mechanism, not the percentage.
The research is old, and the older of the two is not a weakness in the way it looks. The MIT Sloan interviews were published in 1994 and the INSEAD summary in 2017, covering studies from 2000 to 2014. Channels, tooling and the speed of outreach have all changed. What has not changed is the incentive structure, which is what both papers are actually about, and that is why the commitment finding still transfers while any figure on response rates from either period would not.
Approaching the right partner badly beats approaching the wrong one well. Everything above is about the message, and the message is the smaller half. The study findings on rivals, power asymmetry and association ties are selection criteria, and no opener recovers from a target list built out of whoever was at the last conference.
And some partnerships should not be approached at all. If the only thing you want is access to their client list, they will work that out in the second meeting, and the answer will be no in a way that closes the door for years. The cold outreach craft in how to write a cold email that gets replies applies here, with one difference: a partner who feels prospected is not a lost lead, they are a lost reference.
Send us the company, what you think they sell, and the one sentence you were going to lead with. We will come back with a read on whether the power balance works, what revenue event of theirs you could credibly attach to, and a first message you would be willing to put your name on.
Book a Free Consultation